Rare Birds Committee

GENERAL INFORMATION RULES CURRENT REVIEW LIST RARE BIRD RECORD FORM

GENERAL INFORMATION

Why submit a record to Rare Birds Committee of Birds SA?
Records of rarities are of real interest to the ornithological community. They have done a lot to improve understanding of distribution limits, migration routes and field identification of many species of bird. Unfortunately, not every claim of a rare bird is what it appears to be, and this can seriously upset the validity of occurrence statistics.
 
Any author preparing a checklist, field guides or handbook to the birds of Australia or any region of Australia requires an authoritative list of what occurs.
 
If records are not substantiated with some descriptive evidence it is difficult to accept some of the more extraordinary claims that have been made. Some of these records are good and have been documented well. At the other end of the scale, some out-and-out misidentifications have occurred.
 
Birds South Australia needs to maintain a similar standard of rigour to rare bird sightings as already occurs through the Birds Australia Rarities Committee (BARC).
 
An expert Committee of Birds SA votes on what records are accurate and adequately documented, and which ones are not.
 
No records are rejected and the Rare Bird Committee findings are not binding in any way on the observer. Records are either Accepted or Not-Accepted, because of inadequate supporting descriptive evidence. Only Accepted records will go forward to our database of species occurrence in South Australia
 
This process acts as a permanent archive not only for Accepted records but for all cases put before the Rare Bird Committee and Not Accepted records can be reopened at future dates if additional information becomes available, for example a repeat sighting.
Taking notes of what you see
Some birders take detailed notes and this certainly helps ‘clinch’ a rare bird sighting if the notes match the key features of that particular species. Notes on size, shape, plumage, colour of soft parts and “jizz” (the behavioural characteristics) all make up a composite description.
 
It is important to distinguish between what you have seen and what the Field Guide suggests that you should have seen. Word for word descriptions that match the text of a Field Guide are not credible reports. Descriptions that lack some, seemingly significant, information will not necessarily be classed as Not Accepted because their may still be enough information for Acceptance.
 
Obviously it is desirable to see and record as much as possible if the bird is a major rarity. It is also worthwhile taking descriptions of rarities you see which were found by other people. There is no guarantee that the finder of a rarity is going to write it up - and even if they are, it is possible that they will miss aspects that you pick up. Quite often a submission of a rarity includes notes taken by many observers - in fact, the more descriptions taken, the more likely the record is to get through.
What you should do when you find a rarity
When you are fortunate enough to find a rarity there are three simple steps to follow:
 
The sequence in which you do these things will depend where and when the rarity is sighted. Taking a detailed description is the most important of these three steps; it is often not possible to get photos of a particular rarity or to show it to other people, but with detailed notes you should be able to work out what you've seen and document it adequately.
 
Field notes are best recorded while the bird is in front of you. Sometimes this is possible (especially when watching waders); often it is not (a frequent problem for those watching seabirds). Everyone's approach to this problem varies; some take notes very quickly indeed while the bird is in front of them; others like to absorb every detail and write it down once the bird has disappeared, arguing that while they have the opportunity they should spend every second looking at the bird in question rather than spending half of their time looking at a notebook. Do whatever works best for you. The key thing is do get notes down as soon as possible, and in particular to get them down before you have consulted any literature that might have some kind of subconscious effect on your memories of what you actually saw.
Sketches are extremely valuable. However, some bird observers are much more adept at sketching birds than others. It is something one can improve on with practice, however, even the non-talented can annotate their sketches - there is nothing wrong with doing a sketch that doesn't work out perfectly, provided you note any shortcomings.
What is expected in a Submission?
A Rare Bird Record Form can be downloaded from the Birds SA website and will help you to complete a description.
 
However, descriptions will be accepted in other formats, including a photocopy of the actual notes from your notebook.
 
A partially completed Rare Bird Record Form, that has the administrative information, plus a photocopy of your notes is also a practical way to provide a description.
 
Submitting the completed description
Send your submission including any photographs, notes from other observers or any other relevant material to :-
 
Secretary, Birds SA Rare Bird Committee, PO Box 664 Littlehampton SA 5250 or email it to jfmfennell@hotmail.com
How long will it take to process?
This will depend upon the complexity and nature of the submission. Sometimes it is necessary to seek expert advice from overseas ornithologists. Generally a result should become available within 3 months. Although, some extreme cases that involve multiple rounds of voting and or expert opinion may take considerably longer. The observer will be the first to know the outcome.
 
How are records published?
When you have made a sighting of a rare bird the record may still be announced at the Bird Call session at Birds SA meetings and it may also go in the Newsletter. It will carry a qualifier “this record is published subject to review by the Birds SA Rare Bird Committee”. When a record is Accepted this will be announced in the Newsletter and the entry in the Annual Bird Report will state “Record Accepted by the Birds SA Rare Bird Committee”. Records that are Not Accepted will not be published.
Rare Bird Committee Members 2009
Andrew Black
Graham Carpenter
John Fennell (Secretary)
John Hatch
Lynn Pedler
Colin Rogers

RULES

Function of the Birds SA Rarities Committee
To receive submissions and to provide an informed, discerning and impartial appraisal of the records of birds submitted to Birds SA that are considered to be rare in South Australia or are of unusual significance.
 
To maintain an up-to-date and relevant list of those species which the Rare Bird Committee will appraise.
 
To maintain an archival record of submissions and the decisions about them.
 
To regularly publish the decisions.
 
The function of the Rare Bird Committee is to Accept or Not Accept records submitted to it. It does not Reject records and its decisions are not binding on any person.
Membership of the Rare Bird Committee.
The Rare Bird Committee shall consist of up to six members, one of whom shall be the Secretary.
 
The members of the Rare Bird Committee will be required to sign a Confidentiality Agreement.
 
A candidate for membership shall be a person who, in the estimation of the Birds SA Committee of Management, has demonstrated an expert ability in and knowledge of the field identification of birds and who is a member in good standing of Birds SA.
 
A member of the Rare Bird Committee shall be nominated by the Birds SA Committee for a term of one year. All members shall be eligible for reappointment to the Rare Bird Committee at the discretion of the Birds SA Committee. The Birds SA Committee of Management shall also appoint two proxy members to serve on the Rare Bird Committee on an occasional basis.
 
The Secretary shall be appointed by the Birds SA Committee of Management in consultation with the Rare Bird Committee.
The Rare Bird Committee shall have the right to seek advice from other persons, such as inter-state or overseas experts on an as-needs basis.
 
A Rare Bird Committee member shall review records thoughtfully and be committed to doing the work of the Rare Bird Committee in a timely and efficient manner. Rare Bird Committee members will make an initial response to the Secretary within three weeks of receipt of a Rare Bird Report Form for appraisal.
 
The Rare Bird Committee may remove for cause any member who is delinquent in their duties, by a majority vote of all other members and request the Birds SA Committee to nominate a replacement.
 
Receipt of records and distribution to the Rare Bird Committee
The Rare Bird Committee will endeavour to achieve awareness of the scheme through presentation to general members of Birds SA, newsletter articles and website information.
 
Encouragement will be given to submissions in electronic format.
 
The Rare Bird Committee will encourage submissions to be made on the official Record Form, either typed or clearly handwritten.
 
Submissions will be accepted in other forms providing that they contain most of the information as defined in the official Record Form.
Submissions should annex copies of field notes, sketches, photos and other available material and should indicate the fate of specimens.
 
Submissions must contain a complete (as possible) description of the bird (based upon the observed features) and the circumstances of the observation.
Submissions should clearly show the identification criteria, cite references used, and name other observers able to corroborate the record.
 
Observers will be required to self-assess their own confidence in their identification.
Rare Bird Committee Voting Procedures
All Rare Bird Committee members including the Secretary shall cast a vote independently, which will either Accept or Not Accept a record. Rare Bird Committee members will not vote on their own records instead this may be done by an appropriate proxy member.
 
External advisors will not have voting rights. The comments of external advisors will be taken into consideration by Rare Bird Committee Members when making their votes. Not Accept and where required Accept votes at the first round of voting, and all votes at subsequent rounds shall be supported by reasons for the decision expressed.
 
Rare Bird Committee members shall not consult with each other at the first circulation of a record, but may consult before voting at any subsequent recirculation.
 
Upon receipt of a submission each Rare Bird Committee member shall:
 
Not Accept and where required Accept votes at the first round of voting, and all votes at subsequent rounds shall be supported by reasons for the decision expressed.
 
A Rare Bird Committee member may request that expert opinion be obtained to assist in the appraisal of a record.
 
A vote on a submission may be deferred pending receipt and circulation of expert opinion.
 
The Rare Bird Committee should aim to reach consensus in its decision wherever possible.
A record may be Accepted if it receives five or more votes for acceptance (maximum of one vote against).
 
A record may be Not Accepted if it receives two or more votes against acceptance.
 
In the absence of a decision a submission may remain as “Pending”.
 
At the discretion of the Rare Bird Committee, a case may be reopened through the presentation of new and substantial evidence or for other legitimate reason.
 
If the Rare Bird Committee agrees to reopen a case by this means, a decision which reverses a previously accepted record shall only occur by a unanimous vote.
 
The Rare Bird Committee will aim to provide an observer with its decision within 3 months of receipt of the Rare Bird Record Form.
 
The Review List
 The Rare Bird Committee will appraise records of species defined in the Review List, and new additions to the South Australian List including:
It will not appraise records of birds which the Rare Bird Committee reasonably believes to be of captive origin.
 
It may appraise published records which have not previously come before it.
 
The Rare Bird Committee shall compile and maintain a Review List of those species which it will treat based on reported observations over a preceding ten-year period, to a maximum average of 1·5 records per year (i.e. three records in a two year period). Species averaging greater than 1·5 records per year, with sightings in at least seven years of the preceding decade, shall be removed from the Review List by a majority vote of the Rare Bird Committee.
A decline in reported abundance back to a level of less than 1·5 records per year, may cause a species to be returned to or placed on the Review List by a decision of the Rare Bird Committee.
 
Decisions of the Rare Bird Committee
The decisions of the Rare Bird Committee shall be notified to all Rare Bird Committee members and to persons submitting the record, by the Secretary.
 
The Rare Bird Committee's decisions on Accepted records will be published at least annually by Birds SA or more frequently if appropriate. Not Accepted records will not be published.
 
The case files of the Rare Bird Committee are confidential, and may be made available solely to the President of Birds SA and others at the discretion of the President.

CURRENT REVIEW LIST

Casuariidae:
Dromaius baudinianus Parker, 1984 - Kangaroo Island Emu
 
Megapodiidae:
Excalfactoria chinensis (Linnaeus, 1766) - King Quail
 
Anatidae:
Tadorna radjah (Lesson, 1828) - Radjah Shelduck
Anas clypeata Linnaeus, 1758 - Northern Shoveler
 
Phaethontidae:
Phaëthon rubicauda (Boddaert, 1783) - Red-tailed Tropicbird
 
Columbidae:
Geophaps plumifera Gould, 1842 - Spinifex Pigeon
Ptilinopus regina Swainson, 1825 - Rose-crowned Fruit-Dove
 
Diomedeidae:
Phoebetria palpebrata (J.R. Forster, 1785) - Light-mantled Sooty Albatross
 
Procellariidae
Fulmarus glacialoides (A. Smith, 1830) - Southern Fulmar
Thalassoica antarctica (J.F. Gmelin, 1789) - Antarctic Petrel
Halobaena caerulea (J.F. Gmelin, 1789) - Blue Petrel
Pachyptila vittata (G. Forster, 1777) - Broad-billed Prion
Pachyptila salvini (Mathews, 1912) - Salvin's Prion
Pachyptila desolata (J.F. Gmelin, 1789) - Antarctic Prion
Procellaria cinerea J.F. Gmelin, 1789 - Grey Petrel
Ardenna pacifica (J.F. Gmelin, 1789) - Wedge-tailed Shearwater
Ardenna carneipes (Gould, 1844) - Flesh-footed Shearwater
Ardenna gravis (O'Reilly, 1818) - Great Shearwater
Puffinus puffinus (Brünnich, 1764) - Manx Shearwater
Puffinus assimilis (Gould, 1838) - Little Shearwater
Lugensa brevirostris (Lesson, 1831) - Kerguelen Petrel
Pterodroma mollis (Gould, 1844) - Soft-plumaged Petrel
Pterodroma inexpectata (J.R. Forster, 1844) - Mottled Petrel
Pterodroma leucoptera (Gould, 1844) - Gould's Petrel
Spheniscidae:
Aptenodytes patagonicus J.F. Miller, 1778 - King Penguin
Eudyptes chrysocome (J.R. Forster, 1781) - Rockhopper Penguin
Eudyptes pachyrhynchus G.R. Gray, 1830 - Fiordland Penguin
Eudyptes sclateri Buller, 1888 - Erect-crested Penguin
Eudyptes chrysolophus (Brandt, 1837) - Macaroni Penguin
 
Fregatidae:
Fregata ariel (G.R. Gray, 1830) - Lesser Frigatebird
 
Ciconiidae:
Ephippiorhynchus asiaticus (Latham, 1790) - Black-necked Stork
Ardeidae:
Ixobrychus dubius Matthews, 1912 - Little Bittern
Egretta picata (Gould, 1845) - Pied Heron
 
Accipitridae:
Lophoictinia isura (Gould, 1838) - Square-tailed Kite
Accipiter novaehollandiae (J.F. Gmelin, 1788) - Grey Goshawk
 
Charadriidae:
Pluvialis dominica (P.L.S. Müller, 1776) - American Golden Plover
Charadrius hiaticula Linnaeus, 1758 - Ringed Plover
Charadrius dubius Scopoli, 1786 - Little Ringed Plover
Charadrius veredus Gould, 1848 - Oriental Plover
 
Jacanidae:
Irediparra gallinacea (Temminck, 1828) - Comb-crested Jacana
 
Scolopacidae:
Limosa haemastica (Linnaeus, 1758) - Hudsonian Godwit
Numenius minutus Gould, 1841 - Little Curlew
Tringa flavipes(J.F. Gmelin, 1789) - Lesser Yellowlegs
Tringa totanus (Linnaeus, 1758) - Common Redshank
Limnodromus griseus (J.F.Gmelin, 1789) - Short-billed Dowitcher
Calidris minuta (Leisler, 1812) - Little Stint
Calidris bairdii (Coues, 1861) - Baird's Sandpiper
Calidris fuscicollis (Vieillot, 1819) - White-rumped Sandpiper
Limicola falcinellus (Pontoppidan, 1763) - Broad-billed Sandpiper
Phalaropus fulicarius (Linnaeus, 1758) - Grey Phalarope
Turnicidae:
Turnix pyrrhothorax (Gould, 1841) - Red-chested Button-quail
 
Stercorcariidae:
Stercorcarius maccormicki (Saunders, 1893) - South Polar Skua
Stercorcarius longicaudus Vieillot, 1819 - Long-tailed Jaeger
 
Laridae:
Onychoprion anaethetus (Scopoli, 1786) - Bridled Tern
Onychoprion fuscata (Linnaeus, 1766) - Sooty Tern
Sterna paradisaea Pontoppidan, 1763 - Arctic Tern
Sterna vittata J.F. Gmelin, 1789 - Antarctic Tern
Xema sabini J. Sabine 1819 - Sabine's Gull
 
Cacatuidae:
Calocephalon fimbriatum (Grant, 1803) - Gang-gang Cockatoo
 
Psittacidae:
Psitteutules versicolor (Lear, 1831) - Varied Lorikeet
Aprosmictus erythropterus (J.F. Gmelin, 1788) - Red-winged Parrot
Lathamus discolor (Shaw, 1790) - Swift Parrot
Neophema chrysogaster (Latham, 1790) - Orange-bellied Parrot
Pezoporus wallicus (Kerr, 1792) - Ground Parrot
Pezoporus occidentalis (Gould, 1861) - Night Parrot
Cuculidae:
Eudynamys orientalis (Linnaeus, 1766) - Eastern Koel
Scythrops novaehollandiae Latham, 1790 - Channel-billed Cuckoo
Cacomantis variolosus (Vigors & Horsfield, 1827) - Brush Cuckoo
Cuculus optatus Gould, 1830 - Oriental Cuckoo
 
Strigidae:
Ninox strenua (Gould, 1838) - Powerful Owl
 
Tytonidae:
Tyto novaehollandiae (Stephens, 1826) - Masked Owl
Tyto longimembris (Jerdon, 1839) - Eastern Grass Owl
 
Ptilonorhynchidae:
Ptilonorhynchus maculatus (Gould, 1837) - Spotted Bowerbird
 
Meliphagidae:
Conopophila whitei (North, 1910) - Grey Honeyeater
Grantiella picta (Gould, 1838) - Painted Honeyeater
Philemon corniculatus (Latham, 1790) - Noisy Friarbird
 
Pomatostomidae:
Pomatostomus temporalis (Vigors & Horsfield, 1827) - Grey-crowned Babbler
 
Campephagidae:
Coracina tenuirostris (Jardine, 1831) - Cicadabird
Dicruridae:
Dicrurus bracteatus Gould, 1843 - Spangled Drongo
 
Rhipiduridae:
Rhipidura rufifrons (Latham, 1802) - Rufous Fantail
 
Monarchidae:
Myiagra rubecula (Latham, 1802) - Leaden Flycatcher
Monarcha melanopsis (Vieillot, 1818) - Black-faced Monarch
 
Petroicidae:
Petroica rodinogaster (Drapiez, 1819) - Pink Robin
 
Megaluridae:
Eremiornis carteri North, 1900 - Spinifexbird
 
Hirundinidae:
Hirundo rustica Linnaeus, 1758 - Barn Swallow
 
Motacillidae:
Motacilla tschutschensis J.F. Gmelin, 1758 - Eastern Yellow Wagtail
Motacilla citreola Pallas, 1776 - Citrine Wagtail
Motacilla cinerea Tunstall, 1771 - Grey Wagtail

 

This page was last updated on 12/04/2010